top of page

PSI Bulletin: April 22

Apr 12, 2022
10 min read

No. 3/22 SUBSCRIBER EDITION


Thank you very much for subscribing to Synopsis, a monthly publication by Potato Storage Insight Ltd to give you the low-down on everything to do with potato storage.


GB Potatoes' call for support


Now that the wind down of AHDB Potatoes is nearing completion, there is no organisation that represents the interests of the whole potato industry in Great Britain.

GB Potatoes is a proposal from the industry for a lean, efficient umbrella organisation, owned and controlled by growers and the downstream supply chain. It seeks to “be able to defend the industry from threats, when required, and provide a flexible platform for innovation and growth to help the Great British potato industry thrive.” It proposes to be funded by a modest subscription from members.

GB Potatoes has commissioned a website www.gb-potatoes.co.uk which will set out its mission and vision for the organisation. Ultimately GB Potatoes aims to become a trusted and reputable voice of the industry able to effectively represent the interests of all elements of the supply chain.

If you agree with the concept of GB Potatoes, its organisers are saying, “it is very important that you voice your support by emailing info@gb-potatoes.co.uk. There may not be another opportunity.”

Seed initiative proposed too

At the same time, moves are afoot in Scotland to set up a SAOS facilitated co-operative to represent the Scottish seed sector. Also following a membership model, the new group hopes to raise funding from a £40/ha fee based on planted seed. The proposed body is in collaboration with Scottishpotatoes.org a partnership of SRUC, James Hutton Institute and SASA with additional input from NFU Scotland and Scottish Agronomy.


VIEWPOINT:

As a former AHDB researcher, I would submit that it is impossible to underestimate the importance of backing these initiatives. Governments have made it pretty clear that nothing like AHDB is coming back to potatoes and therefore the industry has to provide its own alternative organisation(s) to provide a backbone of support to the sector. Extending way beyond the specialist remit of private companies like PSI, this needs to be present to act as a focal point to tackle cross-industry issues collectively for members (a crucial but highly underrated role that AHDB undertook) and to underpin collaborative effort to drive important facets such as research and knowledge exchange that have been key to our industry moving forward for many decades.

AC



Potato Storage Insight activity


Potato Storage Insight Ltd (PSI) is a new company specialising in potato storage expertise and know-how. PSI has been set up by Adrian Cunnington, former head of AHDB’s Sutton Bridge Crop Storage Research facility that closed in December.


PSI is available to offer support and advice to all parts of the British potato industry, building on our many years of experience, on technical issues and best practice adoption.


March has been another busy month with our own two-day course for store managers successfully run for 20 delegates at Retford. Thanks to Glyn Harper for his help with training delivery and to everyone who took part for their contributions and support.


Heather Briggs from The Vegetable Farmer came along to see how it all went, so you should see some coverage in that publication shortly. Thank you, Heather. Talking of coverage, we are also grateful to Rachel Hicks for her recent article on PSI and our work with sprout suppressants in Farmers Guide and the help of Lukie Pieterse at Potato News Today in widening the awareness of PSI's Synopsis.


If you wish to discuss opportunities for dedicated training for your company, please call Adrian Cunnington on 07970 072260.




Technical insight: STORAGE COSTS

Part One – Energy use


The rapidly-changing situation with storage costs requires every manager to devote some time with a highly critical eye to the matter of cost control - more so than ever before. Burying one’s head in the sand is a dangerous option; costs are rising so markedly that no responsible operator can fail to recognise that getting it wrong could be a disastrous situation for a potato enterprise.

So how can you arrive at an accurate cost for operating a store?

There are many different parts to that calculation. In this first of two articles, we will focus on assessing and regulating energy use. In May, we will consider capital expenditure and other operating costs.


Here are some of the factors to consider when trying to control energy consumption and cost. It is a much more far-reaching list than it perhaps first appears:

· Sub-metering

· Store control

· Calibration of sensors

· Use of inverters/speed control

· Insulation

· Fan performance

· Fridge performance including defrost

· Air leakage

· Box layout and associated airflow

· Lighting

· Use of renewables

· Tariff management


Metering

First and foremost, a meter is key to allow you to record information to help build a full picture of what the store is costing you. Perhaps one of the most common challenges we find is knowing just how much electricity the store is actually using. Fitting some dedicated metering can be extremely worthwhile as it immediately cuts out any guesswork on consumption (eg if the store shares a meter with the grader) and informs the operator on when energy is being used. This can also be valuable for tariff management.


The graph below shows data from an AHDB research project (R439) undertaken in the early 2010s. A metering survey of commercial pre-pack stores was carried out and illustrates the great variation that existed between stores in their levels of electricity consumption. If we ignore the outliers, there was, very roughly, a 250% difference between the best (columns on the right) and worst-performing (left) stores. There is no compelling reason to expect that this situation has changed greatly - but the economic impact of that difference today is obviously more severe, especially since new tariffs have come into force.


Store control/calibration

Getting a good store controller and learning how to use it is important as there are few reasons for running stores on manual these days if efficiency is the goal. If the store is still running on the settings your installer left it on, the chances are it won’t be running in the most effective way. Sensors need to accurately detect when the store has been sufficiently cooled so they turn the fans off and, equally, when it warms back up. If they don’t for some reason, then running times can become extended and expensive.


Use of inverters

An inverter (aka frequency drive) is like a dimmer switch for big kit, such as fans. They’ve been affordable for about 20 years now and can allow changes to be made to ventilation or cooling to meet demand. Typically a fan might be able to run at about 70% of full speed for holding the crop in store compared with what’s needed for drying and pull-down. That will cost less than half the amount to run compared with when the fan is flat out. It gets more complicated if inverters are used on fridges as if the airflow is slowed too much the coil freezes up but the good news for those upgrading a store is that fully integrated systems are now available. Inverters are also handy to manage start-up loads so systems can run on smaller supplies.


Fan efficiency

A fan can use much more value of energy in a year than it costs, so it makes no sense to persevere with old, inefficient fans in many situations. Again, securing some accurate data on which to base any decision for an upgrade is an excellent starting point. New fans can have better start-up characteristics and more efficient blades so you get more blow for your buck.


Airflow


Potato stores use air to shift heat or cold around the store. Obviously, fans play a key part in this but, if the airflow is uneven for whatever reason, inefficiencies creep in. This means the fans run longer than they need to for the same result. Clear paths for air to distribute and a point in the system where static pressure can build to even out the flow – such as a plenum (pictured above) – will make them more effective. Many box stores have not been optimised for this. Stacking extra boxes into a store in the roofspace or ‘headlands’ can also be counter-productive and increase energy use. Extended fan running times also mean more weight loss from the crop.


Fridge performance

Most refrigeration systems will become inefficient over time. An average fridge working properly will typically consume a kilowatt of electricity to produce three kilowatts of cooling. Some might even get close to four. But if the system becomes ‘tired’ and the heat transfer processes don’t work as well this could quickly fall below two. Basically, the heat from the store evaporates the refrigerant at the coil and it is then pumped under pressure to the condenser outside where the heat is released. But if the coils are blocked (pictured below), the refrigerant level is low or the fans are not working fully, the whole process slows down and less heat is removed. Fridge efficiency can also be enhanced using defrost on demand (rather than time-based) or even waste heat recovery if there is a use for it on the store site.



Insulation

Insulating a store is a key part of making it efficient. This helps to eliminate outside influences on the store environment. Factors here will include solar heat gain (or night time heat loss in some stores). Simple attributes like the colour of panels can have a significant bearing on heat gain. ‘Cold-bridging’ is another potential problem if steel or concrete is not adequately protected.


Air leakage

This can be a major factor affecting the efficiency of store performance. Essentially, any potato store is looking to establish a set of controlled conditions (target temperature, humidity etc.) best suited to holding the crop. This goal can be severely disrupted if there is uncontrolled air exchange into or out of the building. Doors, louvres, panel joints, eaves fillers are all potential 'leaky' areas of the structure which could result in a lot of air movement especially if the building is under wind pressure (or, on the lea side of the store, under suction). This leakage can change the conditions in the store very quickly and introduce problems such as structural condensation which then need extra ventilation or heating (adding to the energy bill) to correct. Stores can be assessed for leakage risk by a basic 'light test' - go into the building and turn out the lights - but this can miss factors such as poor joints between panels. The full risk can be accurately quantified by a pressure leakage assessment.


Lighting

Stores need good lights for loading, inspection and unloading. These are relatively short periods of use but, again, an upgrade to low energy LED lighting might be appropriate in an older store. A good switching and alert system is important to minimise the risk of greening should the lights be left on by mistake.


Renewables and tariff management

Many potato store locations lend themselves to solar PV (or even wind) generation and when the feed-in tariff schemes started up in the late 2000s, there was a good (financial) case for installing it even if the energy was exported. The cost-benefit equation is less favourable now that FiTs have ended, so the key to PV or turbine use for potato stores comes from using the energy on the farm. This comes down to control. Some of the newer controllers are now able to prioritise use of renewables in the same way as they manage systems to avoid high tariff periods (eg early evening) to cut running costs. This might mean running a fridge on a sunny afternoon, for example, rather than waiting for less effective cool ambient air in the evening.


For an assessment of the factors listed above, why not book a store audit with PSI? Call us on 07970 072260.


Next month: Part 2 - how to calculate your true storage costs




Topical tips for April


This month, remember to keep a close watch on any stores that are still loaded. For many, it will be a priority to get that next crop into the ground – but what’s still in store will also warrant attention at a time of year when crop condition can change quickly...


Senescent sweetening


As potatoes age, they reach a point in storage - which varies appreciably by variety - when they can develop an irreversible form of sugar accumulation. This is known as senescent sweetening. It is an important characteristic in long-term stored potatoes for processing and differs from low temperature sweetening. Essentially it is indicative of the potato reaching the end of the road in its role as the over-wintering organ of the potato plant as starch in the tuber begins to break down.


Where varieties are stored at warm temperatures, senescence is reached earlier. So anything held at 10C or higher can, by this time of year, be considered at risk. If we add in the varietal component, then watch for a dip in fry quality in varieties such as Arsenal, Lady Rosetta or Pentland Dell. Regular fry testing is the key for any variety and if fry colour does start to fall away, speak to your market and be ready to unload the store.


The onset of senescent sweetening cannot currently be predicted, and results in losses because, unlike low temperature sweetening, any changes are wholly irreversible, so warming up a crop will make it worse not better.


Read more on senescent sweetening on the AHDB legacy website (see Snippets) at https://potatoes.ahdb.org.uk/11140014-phd-senescent-sweetening




Sprouting


Juno Plant Protection Ltd., agents for Biox-M® spearmint oil sprout suppressant, have released a new technical handbook for the product. Single copies are available on request from Juno (nick@junopp.com) or via PSI, email adrian@potatostorageinsight.com.





Maleic hydrazide uptake, by all accounts, seems to have been more variable this season than in 2020/21 but it is important to remember that it now plays a vital role in sprout suppression for many varieties in long-term storage. This is because, since the loss of CIPC, the other treatments available do not really provide any residual control of sprouting. It is that aspect of MH that is important when it comes to retaining suppression during marketing and shelf-life.


As we move towards May, some warm temperature stores have now started to lose that residual element from the MH, which has resulted in a need to treat more frequently with the contact control options such as orange oil or spearmint. Ethylene-treated crops usually keep control throughout the maintenance of an ethylene atmosphere but can also struggle once they are removed from it, especially if any MH residue has also declined.


Regular sampling is recommended to monitor any changes at this time of year.


Don't forget to order maleic hydrazide for summer treatment of your 2022 crop - it will remain important, especially for storage of most long-term processing crops.



Snippets


SAVE THE DATE - FARMING: CLEAN, LEAN, GREEN

Wednesday 11 May, 10am - 3pm

Discussions, exhibits, demonstrations

A collaborative event jointly organised by Anglia Rural Consultants and the University of Cambridge at Park Farm, Madingley, Cambs. CB23 8YW. Attendance is free. More information at www.angliaruralconsultants.com


AHDB 'legacy' website launched

Following the shutdown of AHDB Potatoes, a website is now available designed to ensure previous levy-payer funded work is "protected and accessible". The site contains articles, summaries and other knowledge exchange information delivered by AHDB in addition to research reports. Go to archive.ahdb.org.uk/potatoes


Comments


bottom of page